How to Choose a Business Broker — And the Questions That Separate Good Ones From Bad

Choosing the right business broker is one of the highest-leverage decisions in your entire exit. The right one will find buyers you couldn't reach, manage the process professionally, and close your deal at or above asking price. The wrong one will tie up your business in an exclusive engagement for 12 months while generating no serious buyers. Here's how to tell them apart before you sign anything.

---

What brokers actually do — and what they don't

A business broker's primary function is to market your business to potential buyers, manage the transaction process, and facilitate a closing. They earn their fee — typically 8–12% of the transaction price for smaller deals — only when a deal closes.

What good brokers do well:

• Prepare the Confidential Information Memorandum (CIM) and marketing materials
• Identify and approach potential buyers through their database and network
• List the business on appropriate marketplaces with effective anonymous listings
• Screen and qualify buyer inquiries before your time is spent on them
• Facilitate management meetings and negotiate LOI terms
• Manage the due diligence process and keep the deal moving
• Coordinate with attorneys, accountants, and lenders to get to close

What brokers typically don't do: provide tax planning advice, draft the purchase agreement (that's your attorney), or guarantee a specific outcome. Their job is process management and buyer development — not legal or tax counsel.

---

The most important thing to evaluate: track record in your sector

The single most predictive factor in broker performance is whether they have a demonstrated track record closing deals in your industry and revenue range.

A broker who has sold 15 HVAC businesses in Texas in the last three years has a buyer network, comparable sale data, and industry-specific knowledge that a generalist broker cannot replicate. They know which PE platforms are active, which strategic buyers are expanding, and what buyers in that sector pay attention to in due diligence.

Ask every broker you interview: How many businesses in my industry and revenue range have you sold in the last 24 months, and can you provide references from those sellers?

If they can't answer the first part concisely, or if they deflect on references, you have your answer.

---

10 questions to ask before you sign an engagement letter

1. How many businesses in my industry and revenue range have you sold in the last 24 months? Track record in your specific sector is more predictive than years in business or total deals closed.
2. What is your typical time-to-close from engagement to funding? Industry average is 6–12 months. Anyone promising significantly less is likely overselling.
3. How many active listings do you currently have? A broker with 50 active listings is stretched thin. A broker with 10–20 can give your deal meaningful attention.
4. Will you list publicly, run a private targeted process, or both? Larger or more sensitive deals benefit from a targeted private process. Understanding their approach tells you whether it fits your situation.
5. How many buyers are in your active network for a business like mine? A broker with a warm buyer database for your sector is significantly more valuable than one who will simply post your listing on BizBuySell.
6. What is your close rate on signed engagements? Industry average is 20–30%. Top brokers close 40–60% of their engagements. Below 20% suggests systemic issues.
7. What's your valuation based on, and can you show me comparable sales? A defensible valuation should be supported by actual market data, not a formula.
8. What are all of your fees — upfront, retainer, success fee, and any exit fees? Some brokers charge upfront fees for preparation work. This isn't inherently wrong, but understand the full fee structure before signing.
9. Who specifically will be working on my listing — you or a junior associate? At larger brokerage firms, the partner sells you and the associate manages the deal. Know who you're actually working with.
10. Can I speak with three sellers you've closed deals for in the last 18 months? References from recent transactions in your deal range are the most reliable indicator of actual performance. Any broker worth hiring should be able to provide them promptly.

---

The valuation conversation: the most revealing exchange

How a broker handles the valuation conversation tells you almost everything you need to know about their integrity and competence.

A broker who gives you a high number without reviewing your financials is telling you what you want to hear — not what the market will pay. This is called "buying the listing" — winning your engagement with an inflated valuation, then managing expectations downward once you're locked in.

A broker who reviews your actual financials, produces a value range supported by comparable sales, and explains the factors that could move you higher or lower within that range is giving you real information you can act on.

The broker who gives you the highest estimate is rarely the broker you should hire.

---

Engagement letter terms to review carefully

• Exclusivity period. Standard is 6–12 months. Anything longer requires a strong track record justification.
• Tail provision. Most engagement letters include a tail — a period (typically 12–24 months) after the engagement ends during which the broker earns a fee if you sell to any buyer they introduced. Reasonable, but understand what's covered.
• Fee structure. Confirm whether the success fee applies to the full transaction value or just the cash at close. If you provide seller financing, some brokers will charge their full fee on the total price even though you haven't received it yet.
• Termination provisions. What are your rights if the broker is not performing? A reasonable engagement letter should allow termination for cause with appropriate notice.

Last updated April 2026